Wednesday, March 24, 2010

A Review of The Boy with the Cuckoo Clock Heart by Mathias Malzieu (translated by Sarah Ardizzone)

The Boy with the Cuckoo-Clock Heart
3 out of 5: Jack, the first-person narrator of Mathias Malzieu’s most recent novel, is born in Edinburgh on an uncommonly cold day in April 1874. A clever midwife saves the newborn from certain death by surgically implanting a cuckoo clock in his chest to regulate his weak heart. Abandoned by his mother and sporting a loudly ticking clock for a heart, Jack is destined to be an outsider. Nevertheless, he falls in love with a beautiful girl and, while still a teenager, embarks on a cross-continental journey to follow his love to Andalusia, where she’s originally from.

The Boy with the Cuckoo Clock Heart is an adult fairy tale. As is typical with such tales, many of the characters are thinly developed and highly stylized. Fantastical events and complicated metaphors abound. The novel’s primary message appears to be that our self-imposed limitations are the only obstacles to achieving what we desire. Unfortunately, this rather hopeful message is diluted in the final pages with a jarring and confusing plot reversal, making for an unsatisfying ending.

Malzieu’s unique prose is the greatest strength of The Boy with the Cuckoo Heart Clock. It’s an elegant combination of fairy-tale whimsy and Dickensian realism. Malzieu excels at combining opposite concepts in startling ways, like this example of the juxtaposition of death and birth: "It is so cold that birds freeze in mid-flight before crashing to the ground. The noise as they drop out of the sky is uncannily soft for a corpse. This is the coldest day on earth, and I'm getting ready to be born." The Boy with a Cuckoo Heart Clock offers an unsatisfactory story packaged in beautiful and unusual prose.


bermudaonion said...

I love the title, but I'm not much into fairy tales, so I think I'll skip this one.

Zibilee said...

Oh, I am sorry that this book was ultimately so disappointing for you! I think I will heed your advice on this book and avoid it. At least the writing style was satisfying!

Library Cat said...

Adult fairy tale - not my genre. Even so I have read some YA fantasy type books which were OK to me. This one does not soung promising.